1 Borgata Way
Atlantic City,
NJ
08401
Phone: 609-317-1000
The venerable New York City landmark makes its second home at Borgata, featuring its legendary steakhouse menu, served in a warm, contemporary atmosphere.
3 5 star:
1 4 star:
1 3 star:
0 2 star:
1 1 star:
There are
6 Reviews for
Old Homestead Steakhouse.
6 are 100% Verified
AtlanticCity.com is not responsible for individual reviews posted on this site.
The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our site terms of use.
Red Lace Burlesque - Atlantic City
Boardwalk Hall Arena - Boardwalk Hall
Boardwalk Hall Arena - Boardwalk Hall
Sound Waves at Hard Rock Hotel & Casino - Atlantic City
Hard Rock Live At Etess Arena
STINKS!
Sep 28, 2009 By Christine K
My Review
This restaurant is not the best place at the Borgata. I would not recommend this place to anybody. The food is outrageously over priced and cold when brought to you. We paid 13.00 for a Caesar salad which the server told us was included in the meal--it was not included. I will never eat there again.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
65
Super Filet
Sep 23, 2009 By james W
My Review
Great atmosphere in an intimate setting. Service staff was obviously well seasoned and knowledgeable. Their recommendations were right on. The filet was the largest and best I can remember, super prime. Wine selection was complete and again suggestions were perfect. If you want a special meal not just a steak house, this is the place to try.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
75
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Filet
excellent dinner
Jul 22, 2009 By Isabella F
My Review
The wait was minimal a because we didn't have reservations. The atmosphere was very eclectic. Our dinners were delicious but the service was not so friendly. They were courteous and attentive, just not very friendly. the noise level was fine, not too loud. our berry dessert was very very good
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
50
Birthday Delight
Feb 12, 2008 By Valerie B
My Review
Our entire night dining at the Old Homestead was delicious. Our appetizers were great and the calamari was served with tasty Asian sauce. I would also recommend eating the bread that is offered. My husband loved the onion roll while I enjoyed the raisin walnut. I would certainly suggest ordering steak for an entree. As for dessert, we enjoyed a port wine and a coffee with baileys. It was a meal that was enjoyed and a great to start to a birthday night celebration.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
60
Recommended Dishes/Food:
steak, sauteed spinach, calamari
Old Homestead 5 Stars
Jan 20, 2008 By Nick D
My Review
We had 7 couples with us. It was not my first time there but it was my wifes first time. She was AMAZED at how everything she eat was perfectly cooked. We ordered mostly all the apps for the table to share and almost all the sides for everyone to share for dinner. And not a single thing did not taste bad. The Fillet Mignon was cooked to perfection. As was everything else that everyone ordered VERY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
90
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Anything
excellent
Aug 30, 2007 By JAMES L
My Review
The service was outstanding. The staff accommodated are every needs. They did not rush us and the dirty Martinis were unbelievable. My spouse and myself had the roasted onion soup and a caesar salad which were well above standards. The steak selection was overwhelming. I had the rib eye which was huge and tasty.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
80
Recommended Dishes/Food:
sirloin steak