54 5 star:
20 4 star:
13 3 star:
0 2 star:
5 1 star:
There are
95 Reviews for
Carmine's.
95 are 100% Verified
AtlanticCity.com is not responsible for individual reviews posted on this site.
The posting of advertisements, profanity, or personal attacks is prohibited. Click here to review our site terms of use.
Boardwalk Hall Arena - Boardwalk Hall
Boardwalk Hall Arena - Boardwalk Hall
Red Lace Burlesque - Atlantic City
Borgata Event Center
Tropicana Showroom at Tropicana Casino - NJ
Dining Out
Sep 16, 2008 By June H
My Review
The food and salads are wonderful at this restaurant and it was a treat to dine here. The waitress was friendly and brought our food out in a timely manner. We would definitely recommend this restaurant to everyone coming to Atlantic City. The price was good and sharing the meals is fun for all.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
27
Recommended Dishes/Food:
spaghetti and meatballs
Plentiful
Sep 12, 2008 By Lorna R
My Review
This restaurant is definitely designed for ding of large groups. The food is plentiful and excellent idea for them to have takeaway service for the left overs. The waiters and waitresses are well informative when it comes to the specials.There are times the wait can be lengthy for seating but the wait is worth it.
My ratings are:
Left full
Sep 08, 2008 By Thomas T
My Review
Excellent service. Food was fantastic and very filling. A very nice atmosphere and very quick service. A little pricey but when you're on vacation, you gotta splurge once in awhile and live a little. Would definitely go back again. Menu was a little hard to read as it's posted on a wall, but our waiter, Quinn led us down the correct path with a fabulous meal. Tom Johnstown, PA.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
45
Family Style just like the old days
Sep 07, 2008 By Stephen N
My Review
This Restaurant was one of our favorites because the staff was very friendly and the portions were huge. One dish is enough for two people to split. Desert is big enough for four people to split! The Prices are very reasonable - actually they are cheap compared to all of the other places around the area. Food was delicious. I had a party of 40 people there and it was just as good as my last stay with just my wife. Would definitely go again.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
30
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Linguini White Clam Sauce - Lamb Chop
Delicious
Sep 02, 2008 By Elizabeth W
My Review
The food at Carmine's was spectacular. We didn't have to wait for a table and were greeted by a very friendly staff. Our waiter forgot a few things, but was quick to accommodate us when we asked for something. The portions were huge and delicious. The value of the meal was excellent.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
15
Wonderful
Aug 20, 2008 By Evette R
My Review
Wonderful food & service. Nice atmosphere family style restaurant. Great place to share a variety of dishes. They give large portions. You will have left overs. Great wine list. Servers very pleasant and accommodating. The Salad is wonderful. Everyone should try this restaurant when in NY Time Square area or Tropicana Hotel in Atlantic City.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
30
Recommended Dishes/Food:
sausage penne rigate in white sauce
Dinner with daughters
Aug 08, 2008 By Steven F
My Review
Went there with my two daughters and had the best meal of our entire trip. We didn't have reservations but got in within 10 minutes. The service was wonderful and the food was to die for! I just wish the portions were smaller so we could have had more entrees. Will go back again next year.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
35
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Rigatoni
great
Aug 04, 2008 By melissa W
My Review
Carmines is the best restaurant around. I have been in the Bahamas last year could not wait to go in Atlantic city. We had a great meal and a great dessert. I would recommend this place to anyone. Our waiter was a great guy very helpful, he gave us a great recommendation for dinner.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
35
Recommended Dishes/Food:
chicken special
Great Family Place
Jul 20, 2008 By Caroline W
My Review
Carmines is the best restaurant there is in the Tropicana hotel. Everybody is very friendly and its beautifully decorated. This place is a wonderful place to go with your family. Each person does not get their own meal, but chooses a few, and shares with everybody. The food is amazing, and i would recommend this resturant to anybody.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
30
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Penne Pasta with Vodka Sauce
The famous Carmine's not so great
Jul 18, 2008 By CASSANDRA P
My Review
Carmine's has been recommended to us by family. The food was great but the service was terrible. A warning to anyone who decides to dine there, they do not give out menus!!! You are required to walk up to a wall to figure out your order. It was absurd. I was ready to walk out and go to any other of the numerous restaurants in Atlantic City. Our server rushed us and was not friendly and polite. I feel if I am going to pay that amount of money for food, I should get a menu and good service, at least! Oh and their plates are "family style." That means it sucks if you are dinning for two because the plate is made for 3-4 people. That also means that everyone must agree on the same plate or else you could run your bill close to $150. Generally, I felt unhappy there. There were too many rules and not enough courtesy. I would not go there again.
My ratings are:
Average Meal Price per Person:
30
Recommended Dishes/Food:
Chicken Parmesian